Roll of Honour

Over the four years that I have been working on the listings of Lewis-born casualties from the Great War, I have reached the conclusion that Loyal Lewis Roll of Honour 1914-1918 is a valuable document; but not as reliable as made out by some. Another example emerged today, in the shape of the information on Robert Stewart, late of 4 Scotland Street, Stornoway. His date of death is listed as 16 February 1915; but all the available information points to a Robert Stewart who died of wounds on 24 November 1914. I could publish a list of discrepancies between the Roll of Honour and my findings, but that would not serve much useful purpose. Neither am I claiming that my publication, Faces from the Lewis War Memorial, is devoid of errors. I would like to think though that I am working to eliminate as many errors as possible using whatever sources come to hand.

Private ROBERT STEWART
Last address in Lewis: 4 Scotland Street, Stornoway
Brother of Mrs. Annie MacKay, of 82, North Watson St., Glasgow. Son of Alexander and Christina Stewart of 2 Holm or Garden Road, Stornoway
Service unit: 1st Seaforth Highlanders
Service number: 3/7057
Date of death: 24 November 1914 at the age of 18
Died of wounds
Local memorial: Lewis War Memorial; Nicolson WW1 memorial, right panel
Was called up at the start of the war.

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Fallen from aloft

I am presently trawling the archives of the Stornoway Gazette, looking for tributes to men who fell in the service of King and country during the First World War. The Gazette was not published until January 1917, meaning that the first half of the Great War was not covered. The tributes are incorporated into my WW1 tribute site " Faces from the Lewis War Memorial " (link leads to page with links to tributes). Apart from that, I have also come across a tragic accident, in which a sailor was killed on board his ship. The Gazette reported on 4 May 1917 that the Norwegian barque Yuba had been brought in for inspection. The captain reported that he had found one of his seaman lying dead on the deck. He had gone up the rigging in the dark, and had evidently fallen from aloft. The remains were buried at Sandwick Cemetery. I intend to visit Sandwick Cemetery to find that sailor's grave, and have also found out that the Yuba did not outlive its unfortunate crewmemb...
Read more

Lady Matheson gives away some land

Scottish Highlander, 1 January 1886 Lady Matheson of the Lewis and Her Crofters Lady Matheson has made a fair step in the right direction, having re-lotted part of the Portdue forest which was cultivated many years ago by a happy and contented race of tenantry. A number of Lochsmen have now got lands at fair rent. It is to be hoped that this is but the forerunner of a large scheme of reform in connection with the estate management of the Lewis. [ends] I take Portdue Forest to be the present-day Eishken Estate, bearing in mind the reference to past tenants. 
Read more

Remembering the Fallen of the Second World War - 1939

I have completed the transcription of tributes to the Fallen from Lewis for the year 1939, which comprises the first 4 months of the Second World War. The Stornoway Gazette records 19 losses until the last week of that year, and I am highlighting the following tributes: The sinking of the trawler James Ludford The heroes of the Rawalpindi Donald Macarthur, 10 Cromore Angus John Paterson, 3 Brue Murdo Mackenzie, 21 Swordale Alex Finlayson, 10 Calbost John Montgomery, 16 Ranish The full list of names of Lewis casualties for 1939 is: Murdo Mackenzie, 21 Swordale John Mackenzie, 21 Swordale [Rawalpindi] Norman Macleod, 25 Swordale [Rawalpindi] Angus John Paterson, 3 Brue [Northern Rover] Alexander Matheson, 26 Brue [James Ludford] Archibald Macrae Rodger, 59 Keith Street, Stornoway [RAF] John Murdo Nicolson, 3 Marybank / 39 Lower Bayble [Rawalpindi] William Macleod, Marybank [Rawalpindi] Donald Macarthur, 10 Cromore [Rawalpindi] Alexander Finlayson, 10 Calbost [Courage...
Read more